GAY POWER by David Eisenbach
David Eisenbach’s Gay Power: An American Revolution provides a definitive history of gay and lesbian activism in New York City from the 1950s to the 80s. His study was researched largely through the collections of the New York Public Library’s Manuscripts and Archives Division. Eisenbach begins his study with consideration of the politics of the closet in 1950s New York City. In the 50s, New York had one of the largest and most active gay scenes in the country, and yet, gays and lesbians were continually endangered by public censure, police entrapment and brutality, random violence, and blackmail. Eisenbach shows how Edward Sagarin’s The Homosexual in America helped radicalize gays and lesbians across the country. Sagarin’s book called upon America to recognize and respect homosexual Americans like any other minority group and to stand up against totalitarian politics. He chronicles the rise of the Mattachine Society and the Daughters of Bilitis and shows how their east coast chapters further radicalized those organizations leading to the creation of the East Coast Homophile Association (ECHO) in 1963 and picketing of the Pentagon and White House in 1965. Eisenbach provides a moving account of the Stonewall riots and the radicalization of the gay and lesbian movements that followed with the creation of the Gay Liberation Front (GLF) and Gay Activists Alliance (GAA). Eisenbach fleshes out the chronicle of the emergence of LGBT political power with moving first-hand accounts drawn from interviews such as:
Equipped with helmets, shields, and billy clubs, the riot police lined up, shoulder to shoulder like Roman legions and pushed their way down Christopher Street. Squaring off against one of their flying wedges was a brave, if foolish, group of street kids who formed Rockette-style kick line while singing:
We are the Stonewall girls
We wear our hair in curls
We wear no underwear
We show our pubic hairThe riot police charged into the kick line, smacking the singing youths with night sticks. Over the next hour, gay rioters dodged cops in the winding streets of the Village, setting fires in trash cans and breaking windows. One participant gleefully recalled his experience battling the police.
I developed, in that first encounter, a sense of street fighting tactics, of how to harass and get away with it; of how to taunt and provoke a response and somehow to not get hurt. And just years and years of all the resentments and humiliations and things that can come down on the head of a gay person were really—I was really experiencing liberation and radicalization and everything bang!, right then and there.
Eisenbach shows how the New York LGBT community developed as a political constituency, and has struggled with issues like the right to marry, military service, and the status of homosexuality with the psychological profession for over 40 years. He also introduces us to an entire range of LGBT political activists who are often forgotten such as Barbara Gittings, Kay Tobin Lahusen, Morty Manford, Frank Kameny, Arthur Evans, and Jack Nichols, among many others. Essential reading.
Monday, March 17th, 2008


